Is Europe sacrificing its economy for the climate?
Francesco Caselli, Norman Sosnow Professor of Economics, LSE: “Limiting climate change is a precondition for the existence of an economy worth saving”
Some people may well argue that Europe is sacrificing its economy for the sake of the climate. I would prefer to say that limiting climate change is a precondition for the existence of an economy worth saving.
Sure, it may seem foolish for Europe to increase the fiscal and regulatory costs of carbon emissions when much of the rest of the world pumps carbon into the atmosphere with abandon. Cutting emissions in Europe alone cannot solve climate change. And if European businesses are operating under stricter rules, they may struggle to compete with businesses in other parts of the world.
But we must ask: if leadership on climate change does not come from Europe, where will it come from? China is responsible for the largest share of current greenhouse gas emissions. The United States, the world’s largest economy, has abandoned climate leadership to the extent that it did not even send a representative to the last UN Climate Conference in Brazil and will not send an official delegation to COP31 either.
Limiting climate change is an immense challenge – economically, politically and socially – but European leadership remains our best hope of finding a solution.
Bob Hancké, Visiting Senior Fellow, LSE: “If anything, Europe is abandoning its climate leadership”
Well, if Europe were sacrificing its economy, nobody told the climate. Europe has regressed politically and institutionally on climate policies and has failed to meet substantive green goals it set in 2019. If anything, Europe is abandoning its climate leadership.
The 2035 electric vehicle mandate has been watered down under pressure from Germany and France, the greening of its energy mix has pretty much stalled, and the debate has now resolutely shifted to the “digital race” and competitiveness, even in green tech. Keynes would have asked, how can you be competitive when competitiveness is the norm?
European green leadership is a long-term strategy, with long-term payoffs but sharp short-term costs, especially for weaker parties in the economy and the labour market. Resolving that tension requires not just political leadership but also a sustained effort to bring on board those whose life chances will suffer from both doing little and from a rapid green transition – and the longer we wait, the tougher the transition will likely be – by frontloading some of the expected economic and social gains.
For that to work, we need a radical accounting system that lays out what we are losing by not acting (for those who missed last summer’s heatwaves: ask insurance companies for their estimates). Somewhat absurdly, climate destruction, reconstruction, mitigation and litigation all count as net contributions to GDP today. And, while fiscal policy may look hamstrung, very long-term “green bonds” that, like war bonds, mobilise capital in an emergency and are repaid over decades, are not difficult to design and likely to find buyers in a volatile world.
Governments have responsibilities toward their citizens, including the unborn generations that will have to live with our laconic approach to the climate, and collectively they are stewards of our planet. They should start acting like it. The best time to do so was twenty years ago; the second best time is now.
Richard S.J. Tol, Professor, University of Sussex / Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam: “Climate policy will not ruin the economy – we will miss our targets instead”
Is Europe sacrificing its economy for the climate? If you believe what politicians say they will do, there is a real risk that climate policy will cause severe economic pain. If you instead look at what politicians have done, the forecast is less alarming.
Since 2007, EU emissions fell by some 1.6% per year. The 2030 target is 2.6% per year; 3.5% per year for 2040. Since 1990, UK emissions fell by about 1.3% per year. The UK government plans to increase this to 4.4% by 2030 and 2.6% by 2035. These numbers are particularly daunting as the low-hanging fruit has already been picked.
However, the price of emission permits has not changed much in the UK. It was just short of £50/tCO2 in May 2021 and much the same in November 2026. The EU Emissions Trading System price did increase over this period, from €65 to €85/tCO2. These prices have not led to economic ruin.
Governments embrace stringent targets for after they have left office, but more lenient ones while in power. This has been the pattern since the 1980s. It is unlikely to change. European climate policy will not ruin the economy – we will miss our targets instead.
Fabio Bulfone, Assistant Professor, Leiden University: “Europe risks sacrificing its economy and the climate”
Is Europe sacrificing its economy for the climate? No, Europe risks sacrificing its economy and the climate.
The energy price shock of 2022 highlighted one of Europe’s deepest economic vulnerabilities: its dependence on imported fossil fuels. Investing in renewable energy and heat pumps could reduce this dependence and, with it, the leverage of petrostates. In the long term, therefore, a greener Europe could be both more resilient and more competitive.
Given this energy dependence, EU climate rules should not be perceived merely as economic costs. Instead, they represent a creative use of the EU’s regulatory power, linking climate protection with green industrial policy.
Research suggests that the Emissions Trading System has reduced emissions without systematically undermining firms’ economic performance. The Net-Zero Industry Act and the planned phase-out of new petrol and diesel cars created incentives for businesses to invest in green technologies, rewarding those that did so and penalising those that did not.
It is the erosion of this green resolve, rather than the resolve itself, that now threatens Europe’s economic security and resilience. The strategic and environmental potential of the Net-Zero Industry Act has arguably been weakened by the expansion of its technology list, and the Act was never matched by commensurate funding. Meanwhile, the Commission has proposed loosening emissions rules for new cars, and carbon pricing for buildings and transport has been delayed.
By backtracking on its climate commitments, Europe risks undermining its climate leadership and ending up with a weaker economy and a more fragile society. The real danger is not that Europe is prioritising the climate over the economy, but that it is undermining both to provide short-term relief for entrenched industries.
Source: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/2026/11/10/cop31-is-europe-sacrificing-economy-for-climate/